This
article is an attempt to provide some personal experience and reflections
concerning the use of miniatures from other manufacturers as alternatives to
Games Workshop's Bretonnians. It thereby hopefully addresses two Round Table of
Bretonnia forums on this topic (see Check
out these miniatures and Early
Bretonnian army).
Background
I've
had a long-held fascination and interest in medieval history and this was a
major influencing factor in my choice of Warhammer army. My collection of Bretonnians
comprises almost exclusively all of the previous release of miniatures, since I
am not a fan of the current ones. However, I'd been a collector of Bretonnians since
well before the current release was even hinted at and I'd already amassed a 3,000-point
unpainted army by the time the current
miniatures were put on sale.
My
whole involvement with Warhammer and Games Workshop itself was due to my buying
Warhammer Quest (the final version of the game, before it was discontinued by
Games Workshop). Quest combined many of the aspects and fulfilled the expectations
I had for such a game. Subsequently, I wanted to expand the scope of the game,
by adding more miniatures and giving them greater challenges to overcome. And
that's when it turned into a general 'addiction' for expanding my collection of
fantasy war-gaming miniatures.
Having
collected the full range of Bretonnians available from the previous release, I
wanted to expand my army whilst trying to avoid duplicating the individual
miniatures. I must confess that I begrudgingly added a unit of Men-at-Arms and
another of Peasant Bowmen from the current release, along with one or two
individual miniatures (in particular, both versions of the Bretonnian Lords and
the standing Damsels of the Lady figure, but that's as far as I was
willing to go!).
Whilst
wanting to expand my Bretonnian army, I also wanted to keep with its medieval
theme. In addition, I wanted to introduce other elements of the Bretonnian
population and society, and add some other adversaries for the Bretonnians (and
my band of Quest heroes) to battle against. So I started to look at miniatures
available from manufacturers other than Games Workshop that would meet my
criteria. In my search for suitable miniatures, I believe I've now looked at
practically all the other sources of figures available in the fantasy and war
gaming marketplace. I can tell you for certain that there are more than plenty of
these sources and of varying quality, scale and size (plastic miniatures are
very often sculpted in a thinner form that their metal counterparts).
Scale
versus aesthetics
Without entering a long treatise about scale, let's just say that the scale
height of a miniature is supposed to represent the average height of a human, usually measured from ground to eye
level. However, some manufactures measure their miniatures from ground level to
the top of the figure's head (minus any headgear, such as helmets). To
complicate matters, the traditional scale for fantasy and war gaming, I
believe, is 25mm, but some manufacturers introduced a 25mm 'heroic scale' which
equates (approximately) to 28mm. Hence we find many fantasy war-gaming miniatures
currently produced in 28mm scale, the Games Workshop's Warhammer range being among
these. And, yes, there are miniatures that are now being produced in 30mm
scaleâ?¦
What I've discovered, in my quest to expand my Bretonnian population, is
that 28mm scale is not standardised, i.e. miniatures that are said to be 28mm
scale are not all the same standard height. The picture below demonstrates this
quite clearly.
However, does it really matter that not all 28mm scale miniatures are
the same height? Simply put, No! Because in reality, no group of four or five humans
share the same height, shape, size or body mass. Besides all this, I've never lost
sight of the fact that this hobby of mine is about fantasy war-gaming; the emphasis being on fantasy, i.e. it's
'make believe'.
What does matter to me is that the miniatures, I finally selected to
expand my Bretonnian population (and their adversaries), not only meet my
criteria, but are also esthetically pleasing in their overall appearance and
quality of craftsmanship. Therefore, it's very much a case of personal choice.
Conclusion
So,
what advice would I give to anyone thinking about whether or not to add
miniatures from manufacturers other than Games Workshop to their Bretonnian
army, or any other army for that matter?
Firstly, consider
carefully what basic or specific criteria the miniatures must meet, for
example:
- Army: Bretonnian; Wood Elf; Chaos; etc
- Functional role: General members of the civilian
population; a particular warrior or hero; a member of the merchant class; a
courtier or noble; an adversary; etc.
- Theme: Early Bretonnian warriors; general medieval
appearance; a diorama portraying a jousting tournament or a court scene; a
particular event from Bretonnian history; etc.
Then
consider whether or not the accuracy of the miniature's scale is of personal
importance to you. For example, you
might prefer that the miniature you're adding to your existing army must match
the scale height of all the other figures. Note that this will tend to restrict
your final choice of non-GW miniature.
However,
if the non-GW miniatures are going to represent: (a) an entirely different race
of human or beast, and (b) comprise part of an army against which your
Bretonnians are going to fight, then the miniatures can be physically larger or
smaller in scale height than your Bretonnians. With a Chaos army, for example, there
is a mix of humans and human / beast mutants, so a non-GW miniature of a
slightly different scale would blend in without much difficulty. Don't forget
that Lizardmen vary in size and height, for example, or that there are just
plain short folk like the Dwarf race. So, there's a fair degree of flexibility
in the feasibility of having miniatures of varying height and size (scale) in
your army.
If
you are concerned about the differences in sculpting
style, as well as scale height, then you could always add a group of non-GW miniatures to your
Bretonnians, for example, as a separate unit of say, bowmen, men-at-arms, armed
peasants or even as a mercenary (Dogs of War) special unit. On the other hand,
if you were creating an army to represent a completely different era of
Bretonnian history, then all your non-GW miniatures could be selected from a
range produced by one manufacturer that best meets your theme's criteria. For
example, The Crusades range from Perry Miniatures could be used to represent an
early epoch of Bretonnian history and, by so doing, scale and style doesn't present
such a major issue, since all the non-GW miniatures will match.
Finally, the other
factors that will play a part in what miniatures you select are based much more
on personal preferences, such as:
- Plastic versus metal, i.e. quality and level of
sculpting detail.
- Price and value for money, e.g. 20 miniatures for £20
versus 6 miniatures for £10.
- Available ranges of figures and scales that match your
criteria of theme and race / army.
- Modelling / sculpting craftsmanship and personally
favoured manufacturer or sculptor, or any combination of these.
- The individual miniature's aesthetically pleasing
appearanceâ?¦
Once
you've considered all these facts, I suggest that you buy one or two miniatures
from your chosen source, or sources. These will help you finally decide which
miniatures you want to add and how you will use them in your existing army (or
armies). There's no better way to help you decide than to actually see and
physically handle the miniature/s. By buying just one, or two at most, you
won't have wasted a lot of money if the actual miniature doesn't live up to
your expectations or preferences.
References
During
my search for sources of alternative miniatures, I have viewed a great many
manufacturers' websites and ranges of miniatures, though mostly restricted to
the 25mm and 28mm scale. Just how many actual websites, miniatures and hours of
research are beyond recollection. However, as a consequence of this activity, I
have purchased a good range and number of miniatures from different
manufacturers, which are listed below (with those of a few extra personal
favourites) along with their website addresses. I suggest that you take a look
at these in the hope that it will reduce your own 'quest' for alternative miniatures.
Black Tree Design (Historical
Late Hundred Years War range) www.blacktreedesign.co.uk
Crusader Miniatures (Medieval Europe ranges) www.crusaderminiatues.com
Dark Sword Miniatures
(All available ranges) www.darkswordminiatures.com
Ebob Miniatures (Rebellion, Medieval &
Fantasy ranges) www.ebobminiatures.com
Gamers Quest (Mega Miniatures
Fantasy and Dungeon ranges) www.gamers-quest.co.uk
Gripping Beast (Normans, Crusades, Teutonic & El Cid
ranges) www.grippingbeast.com
Hasslefree Miniatures
(Humans & Demonettes ranges) hasslefreeminiatures.co.uk
Mirliton SG (Historical 25-28mm '
Diorama Kits range) www.mirliton.it
Perry Miniatures (Agincourt to Orleans & The Crusades ranges) www.perry-miniatures.com
Reaper Miniatures (Dark Heaven
Legends ranges) www.reapermini.com
Thunderbolt Mountain
(25mm Arthurians range) www.thunderboltmountain.com
War Games Foundry (Medieval
ranges) www.wargamesfoundry.com
West Wind Productions
(Dwarf Wars ' Nordvolk range) www.westwindproductions.co.uk
Zvezda
(25-28mm Fantasy range. Plastic minis) - very difficult to find now, but some items are still
available from www.ontracks.co.uk
I hope you've found
this article both topical and useful.
Geoff Buss
|